Comparing locations

Run multiple facility scenarios side by side. FRED computes each independently and presents a comparison that surfaces the cost drivers separating the candidates.

#What it does

Real procurement decisions usually involve several candidate sites. FRED's comparison capability runs the full siting analysis for two or more candidates and presents the results in a single comparison view rather than separate threads.

#How to ask

  • "Compare a 20MW facility in Quincy versus Susanville."
  • "How does siting near Burney compare to siting near Redding?"
  • "Show me Lake Almanor versus Greenville for a 15MW plant, with fire weighting."
  • "Compare these three sites: Quincy, Chester, Westwood."

#What comes back

The comparison output shows for each candidate:

  • Annual sustainable supply (BDT/year)
  • LCOE with the breakdown by harvest cost versus transport
  • Operational radius needed
  • Mean burn probability of contributing clusters
  • Dominant terrain class and harvest system mix
  • 10-year supply sustainability rating

The justification paragraph specifically calls out what separates the candidates. Usually it's one or two factors: a notable transport circuity difference, a terrain class shift, or a supply density gap.

#How to interpret

Comparison results often surface non-obvious differences. Two sites that look similar on a map can have very different procurement economics for reasons that aren't visible at the macro view:

  • Road network differences. A site 5 miles away from yours could have systematically higher circuity if it's on the wrong side of a ridge or river. The Pareto curves will diverge as a result.
  • Terrain mix differences. One site's procurement pool might be 60 percent ground-based, while a neighbor's is 40 percent. The cost differential can be substantial.
  • Cluster density differences. A site near a county boundary often has supply on one side and protected land on the other, which limits effective procurement radius.
  • Fire-tier mix differences. Two nearby sites can have very different splits across the four fire-risk tiers, which matters substantially under fire weighting or BioRAM contracts.
TIP
After a comparison, ask "why is X cheaper than Y?". FRED will surface the specific cost drivers separating the candidates, often with a side-by-side breakdown of harvest cost, transport, and terrain composition.