Transport: circuity and haul
Transport is the single largest variable cost in biomass procurement. This page explains how FRED models it, what circuity zones mean, and why short hauls are sometimes more expensive than long ones.
#Why transport matters
At the cost margins where biomass operations live, transport is often the deciding factor. A facility surrounded by abundant cheap-to-harvest biomass can still be uneconomic if the road network forces long, slow, switchback-heavy hauls.
Conversely, two facilities with the same straight-line distance to their supply can have very different actual haul costs if one sits at the end of a well-graded state highway and the other has to navigate forest roads.
#The circuity factor
The circuity factor (CF) is defined as:
A CF of 1.0 would mean a perfectly direct road; the truck drives exactly the straight-line distance. A CF of 2.0 means the truck drives twice the straight-line distance.
Real California cluster origins have CFs ranging from about 1.15 (Central Valley flatlands with grid road networks) to 2.8+ (remote Sierra terrain with switchback-heavy access roads). The variation is large and materially affects cost.
FRED's transport model treats CF as an origin location property. Empirically, the origin location explains 87 percent of the variance in CF; the destination has a much smaller effect. This is why FRED can pre-compute a single CF value per cluster rather than per origin-destination pair.
#The five circuity zones
For interpretive purposes, FRED groups the continuous CF surface into five zones based on natural breaks in the distribution:
- Zone 1 (CF 1.0 - 1.25): Central Valley and coastal flats. Best-case transport.
- Zone 2 (CF 1.25 - 1.50): foothill transitions.
- Zone 3 (CF 1.50 - 1.85): low Sierra and Coast Range. The most common zone for productive biomass.
- Zone 4 (CF 1.85 - 2.30): high Sierra and Klamath terrain. Notable transport premium.
- Zone 5 (CF 2.30 and above): remote mountain terrain. Transport often dominates cost.
When FRED's recommendation includes a notable transport component, the dominant CF zone is usually the explanation.
#The short-route paradox
A counterintuitive finding from FRED's transport research: short hauls have 65 percent higher circuity than long hauls on average.
The explanation is the road network hierarchy. A short haul from a forest cluster to a nearby facility typically stays on low-class forest roads with many switchbacks for the entire trip. A long haul to a distant facility might also start on those switchback roads, but then transitions onto a state highway and runs nearly straight for most of the distance. The switchback segment becomes a small fraction of the total.
Practical implication: a procurement plan that looks better on Euclidean distance (closer supply) can be worse on actual road cost because the shorter hauls have proportionally more switchbacks. FRED's transport model surfaces this in every recommendation.
#Reading the circuity overlay
When you enable the circuity overlay in FRED's chat interface, the map shows the five zones as color bands across the region. Useful patterns to look for:
- Sharp zone boundaries. These usually correspond to ridges or watershed divides where the road network changes character. Procurement that crosses a sharp boundary picks up significant transport cost.
- Isolated Zone 4 or 5 pockets. Visually small pockets of high circuity can be the right places to avoid even if the surrounding terrain is cheaper.
- Highway corridors. The state highway network appears as Zone 1-2 fingers extending into mountainous terrain. Sites near a highway often look operationally better than their terrain suggests.